30 years on from the first Code: A personal account of the Corporate Governance Revolution

Interview with Edward Walker-Arnott KC

We were delighted to have the opportunity to talk to Edward Walker-Arnott KC – former senior partner at Herbert Smith and hugely experienced non-executive director.

With the recent publication of his book “30 years on from the first Code: a personal account of the Corporate Governance Revolution” – we have extrapolated some of the themes and topics for this interview to share with our network of experienced non-executives.



You’ve got a very interesting cross-sector view on governance from operating on so many different boards. How different does the role of the board feel across each of the sectors you’ve operated in and where did you see key themes?

 Everyone on the board must understand the business or organisation: what is the operating model and what is the purpose. That sounds very trite but it’s extraordinary how often those sitting on the board don’t really know what the organisation they are acting for is about.

The importance of the chair is an absolute constant across all sectors – the ability to organise and follow the agenda, get the board to operate as a team and make collective decisions.

The chair and chief executive relationship is also vital – it can be that they are too close or too far apart, but ultimately they should be able to work together and take ideas to the board.

With charities there is a specific consideration – being a board member is typically not remunerated. Many regard being a charity board member a privilege and they’re not assiduous in their attendance or attention, but board members should still be selected carefully in these organisations and be aware of the operating model and purpose as much as a listed organisation.

 

What specific provisions within The Code have been particularly effective in promoting good governance practices and what challenges have emerged?

The most obvious one to me is that you shouldn’t combine the office of chair and chief executive. That’s absolutely critical in terms of managing a dominant individual. It’s really impossible for an executive chair to conduct a deliberately careful examination by the board of a proposal for the organisation.

I also believe it is fundamental to introduce completely independent non-executives, particularly on remuneration committees.  There has been a lot of development in reporting remuneration in listed companies and it is more important than ever to have that independent perspective to give it legitimacy.

The nominations committee is also tremendously important and there should be a very thorough exercise conducted before appointments of the board chair, chief executive and non-executives. It used to be done in a most haphazard and rather ineffective way, but it has hugely improved. We need to ensure that this happens across all sectors and organisations.

An area which needs deeper consideration is that the UK listed sector is contracting, and the private equity sector is expanding. With private equity there is much more privacy and nowhere near the same potential for sanctions or regulation. Governance however does remain extraordinarily important, but it is very difficult to keep oversight on how that is undertaken in that less transparent environment.

 

What role can external stakeholders, such as regulators and industry bodies, play in promoting adherence to The Code?

Quite honestly, I don’t think a huge amount as the sanctions are not substantial or particularly enforced. Regulators don’t really have the teeth in many instances and more often than not there are no repercussions for non-executive directors. The most powerful thing would be disqualification but that happens so infrequently it is largely irrelevant.

 

In light of evolving technological advancements, such as Artificial Intelligence and hybrid working models, how should the corporate governance code adapt to meet the changing needs of organisations and stakeholders?

 In my view governance applies to how you go about making decisions and not about which areas you decide to focus on. AI and hybrid working are two of the areas you might focus on but they don’t apply to how you make decisions, and so the corporate governance code does not need to be altered because of them.

 

Does good governance support and encourage entrepreneurialism or is it more likely to stifle it? Why do you think certain geographies such as the US have a more flourishing entrepreneurial community?

There’s simply no doubt that being disciplined, as it were, by the collective responsibility of the board and all the associated compliance is rather out of tune with the character and vigour of progressive entrepreneurs. The concerns around solvency and corporate governance do not chime with entrepreneurs – they are prepared to take risks and they don’t typically want to be constrained by collective responsibility or undertake the reporting in the volume which is required, and which continues to grow.

We are less entrepreneurial in this country, more risk-averse and more compliance prone than the US. Over there the concern of going bust is less of an issue.

We are not seen as a place to support and encourage growth in the same way. The US has a better and more experienced venture capital market, with a bigger appetite for risk. For example, there are a large number of Israeli technology start-ups and they would always look first to the US for funding or expansion and never the UK.

 

What broader implications does the evolution of The Code hold for the long-term sustainability and success of organisations?

It is possible to have a business which is developing superbly, whose performance is excellent and has a strong long-term trajectory, but in fact has poor governance.

And equally it is the case that you could have a scrupulously well-governed company which is plunging towards disaster because there are so many factors other than good governance involved in the success, or not, of a business.

However, in general good governance encourages constructive challenge of executives from the board.  The good discharge of collective responsibility of a board, as opposed to a small group or an individual being the dominant force, is what The Code is all about and should mean less fraud and less business collapses.

 

In your book you say there are areas where you believe The Code has waded into the political. Can you share examples and how you would like to see it scaled back or changed?

Two examples that I believe are most important are those about the workforce and about diversity. First, the guidance proposes three possible ways of engaging with the workforce, one being that a member of the workforce, identified and appointed by their peers, should be on a board. I think it is a very important point and goes back to 1977 when a committee appointed by the Wilson government argued for workforce representation on boards. But the practical reality of doing it makes it almost impossible. Politicians believe that this is important, but they have no way of enforcing this in law, so they try to use The Code to do this, but it hasn’t been effective.

The guidelines on diversity published with The Code talk about the positive effect on the quality of board decision making by reducing the risk of groupthink. It encourages a broader executive pipeline and puts the responsibility for that on the board, as well as monitoring diversity initiatives.  This is a highly politicised area, as it is of great interest to the electorate and the government puts much emphasis on this. However, it is almost too wide-ranging an area and its emphasis may skew attention away from overall corporate governance. It feels like the politicians are using The Code to help enforce diversity across the business sector, rather than actively undertaking their own policies to address it.

 



If you would like to purchase a copy of the book it can be ordered here. 

Latest

University of Chichester announces appointment of new Vice-Chancellor

DFN Project SEARCH appoints learning disability expert Kirsty Matthews as new Chief Executive

Jonathan Shaw appointed as new Headmaster of Ellesmere College

Elizabeth Newman appointed as Artistic Director of Sheffield Theatres

Queen Mary’s School Announces New Head for 2025

Canterbury Christ Church University appoints Deputy Vice-Chancellor and Provost

Steering the family business forward: Interview with Gouy Hamilton-Fisher, Director Colleagues & Support, Timpson Group

Jewish Museum London appoints Sally Angel as new Chief Executive

Foundling Museum announces new Chair

The White Horse Federation appoints CEO

Social Mobility Day 2024

Concern Worldwide (UK) appoints new Executive Director

Richard Greenhalgh succeeded by Christian Brodie as Chair of United Learning’s Group Board

Royal Botanic Gardens, Kew announces Susan Raikes as Director of Wakehurst

We have moved! Our new London location

Managing Risk in Professional Services: It’s not just about protecting the firm, but enabling it – Interview with Alastair Levy

Crystal Palace Park Trust welcomes Victoria Pinnington as new CEO

Nadia Fall appointed as new Artistic Director of The Young Vic Theatre

How lawyers are coming to terms with their own ‘Now and Then’

Nicola Dudley announced as new Head of Queen Margaret’s School for Girls

Gordon Seabright appointed new Chief Executive of the Horniman Museum and Gardens

The General Pharmaceutical Council appoints new Chief Strategy Officer

A healthy perspective on executive search

Foot Anstey LLP appoints Non-Executive Director

South By Southwest comes to London

Saxton Bampfylde in action with charity Smart Works

Sue Ryder announces new Chief Executive

What will healthcare look like over the coming decade? Interview with Gabrielle Mathews

Liz Truss was correct. Well, on one fundamental point

General Dental Council announces new Chief Executive and Registrar

Andrew Comben appointed new CEO of Britten Pears Arts

Dr Nicholas Cullinan OBE appointed as new Director of the British Museum

Saxton Bampfylde partners with Family Business UK

Professor Robert Mokaya appointed Provost and DVC at University of Sheffield

Celebrating International Women’s Day 2024

Steering the family business forward: Interview with Emma Fox, CEO of Berry Bros & Rudd

Leadership in the age of AI: CEO Breakfast with Doug Gurr, Director of the National History Museum

Sustainability Dinner with speaker James Cameron, Chair of Crown Agents

What will healthcare look like over the coming decade? Interview with Nigel Edwards

Middlesex University announces its new Vice-Chancellor

SafeLives appoints new CEO

Do the right thing: ESG in 2024 – Interview with Lisa Hart Shepherd, CEO of Lamp House Strategy

A Healthy Perspective Podcast – Helen Buckingham, Nuffield Trust

New GPhC Council members appointed for 2024 and 2025

RICS senior governance appointments

An Independent Mind: Sharpening the role of a law firm NED

CLCH appoints new Director of Strategy, Partnerships and Integration

Into Film appoints Fiona Evans as new CEO

An evening for current and aspiring non-executives with Kenny Imafidon

V&A announces Director of Collections and Chief Curator

RNLI appoints new leader to take charity into third century of lifesaving

Erika Lewis appointed CEO at Connected Places Catapult

Alex Frazer Announced as the New Head of Bancroft’s

Sue Baillie appointed as Woldingham’s new Head

Royal Hospital School appoints new Head

The University of Manchester appoints Professor Duncan Ivison as next President & Vice-Chancellor

Championing the Mission – Interview with Jonathan Morgan

Quadrant Chambers appoints Sarah Longden as new COO

New Oasis Community Learning Chief Executive Announced

Rachel Kent made Financial Regulators Complaints Commissioner

Steering the family business forward: Interview with Paul Drechsler CBE

Indhu Rubasingham appointed as Director of the National Theatre

Northumbria University, Newcastle appoints new members to Board of Governors

Professor Tom Crick joins DCMS as Chief Scientific Adviser

Norwich Theatre appoints Tom Sleigh as new Chair

MOSL announces Cliff Kamara as new Board member

Saxton Bampfylde welcomes Partner Hannah Scarisbrick back to the firm

Saxton Bampfylde ranked in Financial Times UK’s Leading Recruiters 2024

The Duke of Edinburgh’s International Award Foundation and Association Welcomes Martin Houghton-Brown as Secretary General

Royal British Legion Announces New Director General

English Heritage announces New Blue Plaques Panel Members

Paul Ridd named Director of Edinburgh International Film Festival

City of Birmingham Symphony Orchestra announces Lord Tony Hall as new Chair

Team Consulting appoints new CEO

UK Civil Aviation Authority Appoints Rob Bishton as the new Chief Executive

The Box appoints Rebecca Bridgman as Head of Collections and Programme

English Heritage appoints Dr Nick Merriman as its new Chief Executive

Breadth and depth: leading across the regulatory landscape

Who’s Moving in Healthcare – August-September 2023

Wise counsel: bringing an external perspective to Higher Education

Looking through a different lens: a scientific scope from academia to government

Outside In: Leveraging External Perspectives in Higher Education

Samori Gambrah announced as Chair for New Art Exchange

Chris Auty appointed as new Director at London Film School

Cherian Mathews appointed as new Chief Executive of HelpAge International

Dr Dave Smith takes helm as UK’s National Technology Adviser

Now Teach appoints new CEO

A Healthy Perspective Podcast – David Hare MBE, CEO of Independent Healthcare Providers Network

Dr Paul Thompson appointed as British Council Chair

Appointment of new CEO for GLF Schools

Bas Javid appointed new Director General of Immigration Enforcement

New CEO appointed for the UK’s national synchrotron, Diamond Light Source

University of Nottingham appoints new Pro-Vice-Chancellor for its Faculty of Medicine and Health Sciences

Béatrice Butsana-Sita appointed new CEO of the British Red Cross

Michael Plaut OBE announced as new Chair of Royal Welsh College of Music & Drama

Will Gompertz announced as the Soane’s new Director

Who’s Moving in Healthcare – June-July 2023

Dr Ghazwa Alwani-Starr appointed as new COO at University of Bath

PA Housing announces five new non-executive members to join board

Storyhouse appoints new CEO: Annabel Turpin